general | April 06, 2026

Fans demand ‘justice for Olivia’ after Bachelor In Paradise messy confrontation Fri 10 November 2023 08:43 Helen Williams

As Bachelor In Paradise heads for its eighth episode, original couples are “falling” for one another, while sparks fly in new romances after the arrival of some fresh bombshells. Some relationships are getting serious but others are falling apart at the seams as the reality show rolls on.

Olivia Lewis pulls Kat Izzo for a chat during Thursday night’s episode after she feels “disrespected.” The Bachelor contestant calls out Kat’s behavior as the two butt heads over the same man. Now, fans are demanding “justice” for Olivia as they feel she’s “done dirty” in season 9.

Bachelor In Paradise star Olivia Lewis looks across at Kat Izzo who is out of shot during conversation on beach
Credit: Bachelor Nation on ABC YouTube channel

Who does Olivia end up with on Bachelor In Paradise?

The Bachelor In Paradise season 9 episodes are yet to reveal whether Olivia leaves the show with anyone.

However, doing what he does best, Reality Steve is lifting the lid on the ABC series and he’s here to dish on what happens to the cast members ahead of the final.

According to the reality TV expert, Kat Izzo and John Henry leave the show engaged.

Olivia reportedly “leaves the show alone,” per Life and Style.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Olivia Lewis (@itslivlew)

Olivia and John Henry

Although John Henry initially chose to date Olivia when arrived in Paradise, things changed when he formed a connection with Kat.

He and Olivia enjoyed a massage date and appeared to get on really well. But, it clearly wasn’t to be.

Per Reality Steve, Kat and John Henry’s connection is so strong that they end up getting engaged in season 9.

Judging by Olivia’s tweets this November, she’s not happy about how things went down in Paradise.

Taking to X (Twitter), she called out her co-star Kylee Russell: “Will shows interest in me and kisses me Kylee messes it up once she catches wind. John Henry shows interest in me and we are together Kylee encourages Kat to mess it up. Anyone else sensing a pattern??”

Kylee responded to Olivia’s tweet, causing a “war” in Reality Steve’s words: “I owe you nothing, I’m loyal to my actual friends. Have a great night :)”

Olivia’s BIP experience may not have ended in romance, but she is getting a lot of love from fans.

Lots of viewers are taking to her Instagram comments to say they think she should be the next Bachelorette.

WATCH BACHELOR IN PARADISE THURSDAYS AT 9 PM ON ABC